Tim Costello Magnolia, Ohio Obituary, Beloved referee and bartending at Tozzi’s On 12th St has died

The Magnolia community is mourning the loss of a beloved local figure, Tim Costello of Magnolia, Ohio, who recently passed away unexpectedly. Known for his roles as a referee, bartender at Tozzi’s On 12th Street, and a dedicated community member, Tim’s sudden departure has deeply impacted many lives across the area.

The Magnolia Area Historical Society expressed their heartfelt sorrow, stating, “The Magnolia Historical Society and the Vince Costello Memorial Sports Complex mourn the sudden and unexpected loss of our member and friend Tim Costello. Tim loved history, loved Magnolia, and above all, cherished his Costello heritage and family. He was an integral part of several projects, most notably our Vince Costello project. He was proud of his Uncle Vince and loved sharing stories and information about Vince’s time on and off the field. An excellent researcher and talented digitizer of films and records, Tim was instrumental in compiling our local sports history as well as cemetery records. He approached his role as cemetery sexton with a historical perspective, always dedicated and meticulous.”

Tim’s presence touched many facets of the community. His work as a referee, his involvement in construction, and his friendly, approachable demeanor behind the bar at Tozzi’s made him a familiar and beloved face. “He was a friend to many and will be missed by all,” the society concluded, extending their deepest condolences to his children, siblings, family, and friends. “Magnolia isn’t going to be the same without him.”

In addition to his community contributions, Tim’s influence extended to the Sophia Capo Memorial Foundation. “It is with heavy hearts that we remember our dear friend, Tim Costello,” the Foundation shared. “For the past eight years, Tim has been an essential part of the Sophie Bowl family, helping coordinate officials and making our tournament possible. More than just the person behind the whistles, Tim believed in our mission, showed up with a servant’s heart, and greeted everyone with a warm smile. His infectious personality made game day even better.”

The Foundation also highlighted Tim’s generosity, compassion, and unwavering support, emphasizing how his presence impacted many lives. “His legacy of kindness will never be forgotten. We are incredibly grateful to have known such a genuine, selfless person. Our deepest condolences go out to his children and family. Rest easy, Tim. You will be missed deeply, and your spirit will live on in the hearts of all who knew you.”

Tim Costello’s passing leaves a void in the Magnolia community, but his legacy of kindness, dedication, and love for his heritage will continue to inspire those who knew him. His life was a testament to community, family, and service, and he will be remembered fondly for the many ways he touched lives around him.